Nicole Kidman made her first appearance on The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon since January 2015 when she hilariously revealed that she and the host had actually gone on a “date”—unbeknownst to Jimmy—many years ago at his apartment when a mutual friend connected them.

On last night’s episode (Nov. 17), Nicole revealed that Jimmy missed another chance to court the Aussie actress when he failed to ask for her number at a party at director David Fincher’s house years ago.

“It was when Brad [Pitt] and Jen [Aniston] were still together, so it was a long time ago, and you could have asked for my number then . . . and you still didn’t ask for it,” said Nicole, as an exasperated Jimmy tried to recall the encounter. “We were lurking in the kitchen after everyone went out and I’m like waiting and waiting and waiting. This is so true and you know it.”

After more awkward banter, Keith Urban came to his wife’s rescue when he surprised the audience—and Jimmy—by swooping in with a guitar and singing “Dream Weaver.” Keith planted a kiss on Nicole and joined the interview for even more AWKWARD banter.

Check it out below.